top of page

Therapy or coaching — where do you start?

Writer: Dave Flint : MBACP (Accred) : BSc (Hon) Psychology
Dave Flint : MBACP (Accred) : BSc (Hon) Psychology
Oct 24
3 min read

Updated: Nov 1

Perhaps you have reached the point where you would like to talk to someone, but looking for that person has given you another decision to make. Counselling, psychotherapy, coaching: which are you supposed to choose?

You might be managing work, looking after your family and getting through the week, while knowing that something feels difficult. Or there may be one particular decision you have gone round and round without getting any closer to making it.

It can be tempting to put off contacting anyone until you have worked out exactly what you need. I would be quite happy for that uncertainty to be part of our conversation.

two men chatting over coffee
therapy or coaching - what suits you?

What would you like help with?

Imagine you are considering a different job. You have looked at vacancies, thought about the money and perhaps even started an application. Then you stop. A few weeks later, you do much the same thing again.

There could be some very sensible reasons for hesitating. You may have responsibilities that make a move difficult. You may like parts of your current job and be reluctant to lose them. You might also wonder whether you could manage the new role, even though your experience suggests you could.

I would want to hear a little more before deciding what that hesitation means. What appeals to you about leaving? What would you miss? Whose expectations are involved? Perhaps, as we talk, it turns out that changing jobs is not what you want after all.

That is an imagined example, but it shows why a label such as “lack of confidence” only tells us so much. The detail matters. So does having room to change your mind about what the difficulty actually is.

Where counselling and coaching differ

Coaching might suit a focused piece of work around that decision: considering your options, understanding what matters to you and deciding what you want to do next. There can be room to explore feelings and doubts within that work.

Counselling or psychotherapy may be more appropriate if the conversation needs to give fuller attention to distress, difficult experiences or patterns affecting several parts of your life. You may want time to understand something you have carried for years, or help with something that has happened quite recently.

Those descriptions are starting points for a discussion. Wanting practical change does not automatically mean coaching is the answer, and being upset does not settle the question either. We would need to consider what you are bringing and agree a suitable focus.

In my psychotherapeutic coaching work, I draw on my training in both psychotherapy and coaching. That allows us to explore what may be getting in the way while also considering what you want to do about it. If it becomes clear that a different kind of support would be more appropriate, we can discuss that openly.

You can ask me questions too

When you are choosing someone to work with, it is understandable to concentrate on explaining yourself. But you are also getting to know the person sitting opposite you.

You might want to ask how I work, what experience I have with the sort of difficulty you are describing, or what I mean by a particular approach. You might want to tell me that you have tried something before and did not find it helpful.

I would want to hear that. It helps me understand you, and it gives you a chance to decide whether my way of working feels suitable. There is room for “I’m not sure about that” in the conversation as well.

A place to begin

If you are wondering whether to choose counselling or coaching, try thinking about one recent moment when you wished something could be different. What happened? What was difficult about it? What would you have liked instead?

You do not need to write an account or arrive with answers to all three. It is simply one way of finding somewhere to start if the whole situation feels too much to explain.

You can read more about how I approach the distinction in Therapy or Coaching: What Kind of Help Do You Actually Need?, on Charles Flint Therapies. There is also more information about my psychotherapeutic coaching work.

And if your starting point is still “I’m not sure what I need”, you are welcome to say exactly that.

Comments


bottom of page